Addressing the Operational and Financial Challenges of China’s Toilet Revolution
China’s rural sanitation landscape has undergone a significant transformation in recent years through the government-led “Toilet Revolution” initiative. This ambitious program aims to achieve universal access to sanitary toilet facilities across the country by 2030. While the Toilet Revolution has made considerable progress, our survey of 656 rural households across 10 provinces revealed persistent operational, financial, and management challenges that threaten the long-term sustainability of the program.
One of the key findings was the widespread reliance on government subsidies and support to fund toilet renovations, with a majority of households unwilling to invest their own resources. This “build first, manage later” approach has led to a lack of formal models for operations, maintenance, and monetization of sanitation products and services. Over 85% of respondents reported an absence of any structured business approach, with most households responsible for self-built and self-maintained facilities.
To address these critical issues, we propose leveraging a “sanitation value chain” framework that integrates both governmental and private sector involvement. This comprehensive approach can enhance the financial viability, operational efficiency, and long-term sustainability of rural sanitation systems.
Unlocking the Potential of the Sanitation Value Chain
The sanitation value chain theory suggests dividing the internal value chain into core and auxiliary components to foster market dynamism and improve the sustainability of sanitation services. The core value chain encompasses the essential activities, such as procurement, production, operation, and marketing of sanitation facilities and products. The auxiliary value chain, on the other hand, supports these core activities through financial management, human resource development, and technological innovation.
Enhancing the Core Value Chain
Within the core value chain, cost management is a crucial consideration for profitability. Our survey revealed that the predominant route for toilet construction in rural China involves public tenders and collaboration with project management contractors. In the Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region, for instance, a private entity secured a contract for toilet construction at approximately CNY 4,000 per household, with the government subsidy covering around CNY 3,000, leaving households responsible for only CNY 1,000.
However, our findings also showed that 23% of respondents were unwilling to invest even CNY 1,000 or more in toilet renovations. This suggests that private toilet construction companies must explore innovative cost-cutting strategies, such as leveraging local materials or adopting more cost-effective design solutions, to improve affordability and accessibility for rural households.
Another strategic avenue for enhancing the core value chain is revitalizing the rural sanitation market. Currently, rural households in China have limited choices in toilet design and sanitation technologies, as they are largely dependent on government directives. By leveraging the model of existing online shopping platforms, toilet products and services could be made more readily accessible to the public, potentially driving competition, promoting innovation, and improving service delivery.
Strengthening the Auxiliary Value Chain
The auxiliary value chain focuses on supporting the core activities through effective financial management, human resource development, and technological innovation. One innovative financing strategy that can be explored is the Public-Private Partnership (PPP) model, where the government can incentivize corporate investment through policy support and tax incentives.
Our survey revealed the positive impact of adopting the “who invests, who benefits” principle in Shandong province, where PPP collaborations have attracted social capital in constructing tourist-friendly toilets. This approach not only bridges funding gaps but also aligns investor interests with public sanitation goals.
Another critical challenge within the auxiliary value chain is financing the ongoing operation and maintenance of sanitation systems. Reinvesting potential profits derived from resource-oriented sanitation systems that produce valuable products, such as fertilizer and biogas, can be a viable solution to overcome this challenge.
However, our study found that barriers to recycling human excreta, including inadequate technology, prohibitive costs, and persistent odor issues, have rendered the sale of toilet products economically unviable. Consequently, the financial viability of rural sanitation systems has become heavily reliant on government subsidies, which are vulnerable to policy shifts and budget cuts, potentially leading to system neglect.
Harnessing the Power of Community Engagement
Achieving the full potential of the Toilet Revolution in rural areas will require a collaborative effort involving government bodies, private enterprises, and the local community. While our survey revealed a predominant view among respondents that the government is the primary driver of sanitation initiatives, government efforts alone may fall short in fostering long-term sustainability.
Enhancing community engagement and awareness is crucial to ensure broader support and participation in the Toilet Revolution. Our findings showed that less than 5% of respondents had a clear understanding of the program’s objectives, despite 43% having received some level of publicity and training. Targeted education campaigns and the incorporation of user feedback can help align household priorities and preferences with the goals of the Toilet Revolution.
Conclusion
The insights generated from our survey of 656 rural households in China highlight the pressing need to rethink the implementation approach of the Toilet Revolution. By leveraging a comprehensive sanitation value chain framework that integrates both governmental and private sector involvement, the program can address the persistent operational, financial, and management challenges.
Key strategies include:
- Improving cost management through innovative design solutions and the utilization of local materials
- Revitalizing the rural sanitation market by leveraging e-commerce platforms to enhance choice and accessibility
- Exploring innovative financing mechanisms, such as Public-Private Partnerships, to bridge funding gaps and align investor interests with public goals
- Enhancing community engagement and awareness to ensure broader support and participation in the Toilet Revolution
By adopting a more holistic and collaborative approach, the Toilet Revolution can unlock its full potential, delivering sustainable and equitable access to sanitary toilet facilities across rural China.
For more insights on construction, design, and sustainable building practices, visit https://localbuilderlondon.co.uk/.
